Elgin Mining (ELG.V) made an offer to buy out Gold Ore Resources (GOZ.TO) in an all stock transaction nominally at a premium of 66% to GOZ.TO's recent closing price. As of 9:40AM GOZ.TO is trading up 25% relative to yesterday's closing price.
Here's my take on the situation:
- GOZ.TO is a small (44K oz/year), high-cost gold producer with a mine in Sweden that is making a lot of money at current gold prices, but which has no growth prospects.
- ELG.V is a mine reopener of a high-grade mine in the middle of nowhere (see any towns, roads, cities anywhere near the mine in the map below?) in the Northwest Territories of Canada. The mine closed in 2005 due to low gold prices. They have at least one big-name executive (founder of Kinross Gold is the Chairman).
- I hate mine reopeners as I lost a tonne of money in 2007 on base metal mine reopeners. The mines look like money makers at current metal prices and then they are un-economic and "go to zero" when the price declines.
- But, I remain bullish on the price of gold.
I've decided to sell all my GOZ.TO even though it looks on the surface like the mine reopener will work. Here's why it looks like the mine reopener will work:
- The cash cost of that ELG.V mine has got to be entirely driven by the price of fuel since there are no roads. Transporting fuel and equipment and people, etc. in and out has got to be the primary cost driver for that remote mine.
- So, whether that mine reopener remains profitable depends primarily on the ratio of the price of gold to the price of fuel (see chart below).
- The price of gold relative to oil now is approximately twice what is was in 2005 and is trending higher and has been consistently higher ever since 2009. This seems very promising.
- As long as this remains the case the mine reopener will probably "work",
However, in the light of my reasoned conclusion that Peak Oil is "real" and "significant", I just don't want to touch anything that completely depends on the price of oil staying low relative to any other thing including gold. I don't like high-cash cost gold producers that use diesel either for power generation or for open-pit mining. I'M OUT.
MontyHigh, www.worldofwallstreet.us
- No growth prospects, no chance of increasing production above that 100K oz/year level that seems to cause gold miners to get a decent valuation.
- No commitment to returning profits to stockholders with either share buy-backs or with dividends.
Next time I buy into a gold-miner value play there has got to be an exit strategy.
Recent Comments